Yesterday, I blogged about Alex’ adoption to this great couple from Idaho. Well, today, the adoption got undone. There wasn’t anything wrong with Alex — in fact, he exceeded their expectations because (for example) he enjoyed riding in the car and didn’t cause conflict with Bunnie (their existing Sheltie). However, Diane and Tom thought that Bunnie appeared to be very depressed at having to share her life with a second dog, so after a lot of discussion, they decided that perhaps it was not the right time and/or the right Sheltie.

So, very early this afternoon, Tom drove down from Ogden with Alex. We’re all sad that it didn’t work out, because they would have made a fantastic home for Alex. But we also realize that sometimes, even for reasons that are tough to articulate, adoptions just don’t feel right. This was one of those times. They very generously refused to take back the adoption fee, turning it into a donation to Sheltie Rescue. (Thanks, Tom and Diane!) Then, Tom headed off to pick up Diane and Bunnie and start that long drive back up to Moscow, ID.

While we’re sad that it didn’t work out (as I’m sure Tom and Diane are), I want to emphasize that there are no hard feelings about anything here. The prospective new family for Alex did exactly the right thing. If the adoption isn’t 100% good for all three parties (the adopting family, Sheltie Rescue, and the Sheltie), then it should be undone. We’re impressed that this couple were able to work that through under so much time pressure and do the right thing.